Today was my first experience with Cleveland Pickle. I ordered a side of pasta salad and the Blazin River. Contrary to what other yelpers say, I enjoyed the pasta salad (perhaps they've changed their recipe). It was slathered in dressing and yummy. I was taken back by how comically small the portion was, however it was only $1.50. If you are hankering for a big portion of pasta salad I would order several servings of it.
The Blazin River was good, however I probably wouldn't order it again. The chipotle sauce didn't quite do it for me. I was hoping for more of a tangy sauce since the menu stated that lime was an ingredient. I felt the lime got lost a bit especially when competing with the overall spicy level. The size of the sandwich is large, so you do get a lot for your money.
I'll definitely be back to sample more from their menu.