We saw Andreoli's on Triple D and had it on our list of places to go. We love authentic Italian and have a place in Scottsdale I have been going to for 45 years which was also on Triple D.
We came up from Chandler and were so hungry! Love the different tables and chairs with a real Italian feel and decorations. There was a table full of what looked like family members and chefs/employees, near the register and it confused us as to where we order.
The young man at the counter was super helpful and we ordered 3 sandwiches and the fries with leeks. Total bill for 3 people for lunch was $36. OK, I guess. The place was nearly empty but we waited quite a bit for our food.
I had the salami, cheese and olive sandwich which was small with a small sliver of cheese, and 4 circles of salami. The rolls were delicious but I would think you could get a little more meat and cheese than that. The quality is excellent without question but it just wasn't anything I would come back to if we weren't in the area. It felt like we were outsiders and not very welcome.
The fries with fried leek were outstanding! This is the only reason I gave 3 stars instead of 2.
We will go back to our favorite place in Scottsdale but wish Andreoli's well.