I like this place. It's very... comfortable... It was warm from the cold outside. (I'm a native!!! I can't take 65 degrees!)
And smells AMAZING. Their pizza smells so good, it's ridiculous.
Walk in... they do have a bar... complete with barstools, neon signs, "tacky" (but I like them) posters from movies...
We sat in the group section. I was coming in expecting to have their cookie with ice cream to celebrate my birthday and leave.
We ended up having the Soho Salad Pizza, Fried Calamari, and then their Cookie.
I've had their pizzas in the past (pre-Yelp) and I really liked them.
You know... their Soho Salad Pizza was GREAT. Four stars. Completely makes you feel that you are not eating something high in calories AT ALL. Very tasty and we would definitely order it again. I was telling my partner that it was reminiscent of CPK's salads. Almonds, feta cheese... and of course the awesome dressing that wasn't too heavy.
Calamari... I was ok with it. Three stars for me. While I agree that I've had better, I didn't think it was terrible, but at the same time, it could have been crispier and with more seasoning. It was fairly bland. I think the sauces that went with it made it.
And of course, the cookie. Halfway cooked... just the way I liked it with two huge scoops of vanilla bean ice cream. :) 5 stars. :) Gooey... warm... soppy... perfect. :) And it's not too big. Sharing between two people isn't uncomfortable for the belly... even after having the Soho Salad Pizza and the Fried Calamari.
We'll be back. I want to have their pizza again. :)