Ok, I finally went to Pugzie's after driving past it umpteen times. It's okay. Nothing amazing, nothing awful. The set-up is tres bizzare. Very large open seating area with dual counters, one for your main meal and a smaller for dessert...except that you can buy some desserts at the main counter. Seems like it should all be in one place or no desserts at the main.
The bathrooms are outside across the courtyard. Obviously the building style is old but considering how much space is wasted in the dining room they could probably put the john in there and you'd never know. And the whole thing is painted like the Golden Girls lanai. Whoa.
The food. Sandwich was decent, crab salad was much too salty. Cookie was delicious and chewy yet with a little crispness on the underside. I had a brownie that was pretty good too, on the cakey side as brownies go. If I am going to pay over $6 for a sandwich I prefer leaf lettuce not shred.
One hing I very much enjoyed was the counter seating for singles. The counter top is deep enough to comfortably hold work and your lunch tray!
The service was friendly and the place kept clean. While I can't imagine a craving causing me to return I will probably check it out one more time and order something completely different just to round out my impression.