I'm from Youngstown, OH, the birthplace of Handels so I'm probably a little biased, but it is the most amazing ice cream.
I've tried several different flavors over the years. My absolute favorites are peanut butter parfait, chocolate, blue moon & pink champagne (they rarely have it in Pittsburgh). They are all creamy & delicious. The milkshakes are to die for and are also creamy & delicious.
I was not as wild about the cake batter. There is no cake in it like you find in others & it just tastes like vanilla. I was not huge on the chocolate peanut butter brownie.