Full disclosure - I am not a student. I was a student many moons ago and often went to the Den and the Black Lounge for those busy Thursday nights.
This review is based on me going for lunch at the Black Lounge with a friend that works at the University.
Many things have changed since I was a student. Most importantly, I now actually have money, tend to care more about what I eat, and don't just have chips and salsa and 2 beers for lunch.
I had the fish tacos for lunch (and no booze - shocking I know) and they were ok. My big beef with many places that do fish tacos is that so often the veg portion is super wet and as soon as you try to pick it up, the tortilla disintegrates and you're left with a soggy taco salad. My friend had the pizza and it looked really good so I think this was just a question of ordering the wrong thing.
If I was a betting person, I imagine that the best bets at a place like this are booze and anything fried.
Bottom line - students will love it, others may not.