If I got hung up too much on intangibles, I could give Muldoon's 4 stars, and if there was a 3.5 option, I'd give the extra half star.
Outstanding beer selection and really really good pizza. Used to go to Muldoon's about once a week with my wife, and after a couple of merely "okay" experiences, we stopped. We've been back a couple of times recently and enjoyed ourselves. Good basic pub grub and some very good specials.
The staff are extremely friendly and make you feel very at home.