As with most things Pittsburgh, this place over-promises and under-delivers. The chocolate is good but not near to the best, and the ice cream isn't their own or even a local boutique brand, but rather Perry's. Nothing wrong with Perry's, but it's nothing special, and it's widely available elsewhere. The ice cream portion sizes are SMALL compared with those provided at many other ice cream shops, so a single is literally one dip of the scoop, and a rather stingy one at that. They do mix a good milkshake, though.