We were nearby at St. Joseph's hospital, so, while my wife was waiting, I picked up a pizza to go for the both of us.
To me, what takes them from a 4 to a 5 is that while I was waiting, I remarked on the great beer selection they have there. As a treat, the server gave me a sample of a limited edition beer.
The pizza came quickly and was nicely cooked. Given the great pizza choices in the city, this competes well. I'd say just a touch below Libretto and QMP. When in the area, and yenning for something simple, I'd do this all over again. I'd bring friends here too.