These guys changed ownership again sometime between november and december 2014 and while the previous owners definitely dropped the ball, the new owners are great!
We went for AYCE on a sunday evening while they had the 30% off promotion. Having been a couple times before this new change in ownership I was wary - but their new chef is great, the service was lovely and although they were fairly busy for sunday night dinner we never had to wait more than a minute or two to order new items or get a refill on our tea.
The enoki beef rolls are a bit smaller than they were previously but they taste even better. The rolls were all fresh and tasty. We had at least 8 different rolls. The eel was perfect and the white tuna was tasty. I was so impressed I plan to have my annual birthday sushi here in March! (Which is usually a group of 15-30 people)
The new owners have really turned the quality of the AYCE service around. If you have been here before and were disappointed I recommend that you give new sushi island once more chance. Granted this is still AYCE so you aren't going to get the quality you would if you were paying by the roll (Ie. I have paid $45 dollars for two rolls and 6 pieces of sushi and they were exquisite) but if you want to chow down on sushi for two then this is a great deal. They had a couple tiers of sushi. 16.99 and 19.99 options from what I recall. We went with the 19.99 as my boyfriend likes sashimi.
Great value for under $50 for 2 people to have dinner