I'm a big fan after my one visit.
This is a small, neighborhood Italian pizza place tucked a little out of the way. The prices are reasonable and the place definitely isn't dressy. The owner really does greet everyone who comes in like family and a lot of people by name. He seemed to make a big deal of asking and using people's names so either he is really good at memorizing or people are repeat customers.
We had pizza. It was really good New York style. They have a few creative types of pizza on the menu, but we didn't try them. I'm a native of NYC (a long time ago) so I tend to want pizza that sticks to the basics. That they nailed. We didn't have dessert or anything like that as a lot of other reviewers do, because, well, its a pizza place. Actually, its probably becoming more of an Italian Restaurant, and if so you probably can have dessert, but to me its a neighborhood pizza place, and for that it got 5 stars.