A friend introduced me to the Bou. I love the small townie feel of the bar. MOST patrons, especially the regulars are welcoming. I have yet to have the food, but getting drunk here as the first and/or last stop is always awesome. My favorite bartender is Winslow! For many reasons but my top reason, well, that man is a beast! With an overpacked bar he can remember you're drink, to refill and has the most positive attitude in chaos. If your feeling like you want rowdier scene, downtown Madison isn't far, so hop on a bus or a cab and you got a good night.
*2/24/17 update: food is great!