I went there for an early dinner recently and overall it was a fun experience, albeit an expensive one. The prices are higher than the quality and that's really the bottom line here. The service was excellent. Every member of the staff we encountered was professional, knowledgable, and personable. The food, while overpriced, was still very good. I ordered the half serving of the stuffed pork chops and it was very tasty. The cannoli for desert was very good as well. Others at our table ordered a wide variety of items, to which the consensus was the food was great.
So, really you are paying for the ambiance and the service. The interior of the restaurant is dark and has an old school feel to it, which to me is awesome. The only sticking point is the prices on the menu, where I feel you can absolutely get food at least as good at other places for a better value. I will go to Casa Di Amore now once in a while to change things up, but not as my mainstay italian restaurant on town.