To tell you the truth, my apartment is across the street and I pretty much have "Cheers" status (they know me by name) so I might be bias with the 5 stars. But wanted to state the things I like from a local prospective.
First if you haven't looked inside, do it! It use to be an old bank and then turned to a bar. Its actually really stunning so don't let the saloon part throw u off.
Second, games everywhere! Also every Monday it's free games. Pool, air hockey, golden tee, pop a shot, etc. everything is free (except for that punching bag game)
Third, great place to pregame before tribe and cavs games since it's so close.