Ahhhh the "eccentric" store. I really don't find anything "eccentric" about this store, and I'm going to have to agree with Emily that Red Pegasus is great.
As much as everyone wants to be the giver of a practical gift, when it comes down to it, practical gifts are not as much fun. It is much more fun to pamper someone with a gift they don't actually NEED but will definitely love. Red Pegasus is the place to find these kind of gifts. Some will be silly, some may even be stupid, but there will be thought put into it and the person will know you care. Awwww.
Red Pegasus has all sorts of fun gift ideas, as well as locally made products from jewelry to home decor. It's a great place to support Toronto artists, or to find the perfect gift. And it's close to a lot of good restaurants so you can grab delicious food after :)