Why 5 stars? I couldn't find anything wrong with this place.
The decor, as mentioned by many others, is gorgeous, warm and welcoming. Both counter staff greeted us with a friendly "hello".
My wife and I each had a (non gf) savoury scone (mine broccoli and cheddar, hers mushroom and something else), both of which were delicious.
When I see an Elektra espresso machine, I can't resist, so both my wife and I had a flat white (hers decaf, mine caf), and they were also very good. I drink a lot of espresso and milk based hot beverages (coffee list here http://www.yelp.com/list/coffee-toronto-2), but wouldn't have known that these were made with soy milk if I hadn't read it on the chalk board after the fact. They get their beans from Merchants of Green Coffee. http://www.yelp.com/biz/merchants-of-green-coffee-toronto
Great ambiance, great products. We'll definitely be back!