After seeing that Andrea's Gerrard Street Bakery's butter tart was voted #1, my husband and I had to stop by to pick one up several months ago. This one almost sent me into a diabetic shock. (And no, I do not have diabetes). (Luckily) We bought one to share; we could only eat half of it and threw the other half out. It is far too sweet. The crust does not rival that of my favourite butter tart either.
Service here also leave something to be desired. The lady who was helping us out wasn't very friendly.