It's very possible that if I were to move away from Madison (having lived here now for nearly 15 years) that upon a return visit, the Weary Traveler would be my first stop. This restaurant never disappoints. Their Old Fashioneds are some of the best in town.
Two of my favorite items on the menu include the Goulash and the West of the Andes Sandwich. Friends of mine swear by the Bad Breath Burger. The menu is on the smaller side but I've never gotten something I didn't like.
And save room for Key Lime Pie. One can almost guarantee when I go out for dinner I won't get dessert. The Weary Traveler is my exception to that rule.