So after a miserable renting experiencing from the only paddle board rental guy up at Lake Pleasant (I won't even give out the business name) I gave NoSnow SUP a try and wanted to check out Saguaro Lake.
The location is great as they are on the way to the lake and Salt River. They are always going group outings as well which you can find on Meet Up or just call them and they'll fill you in. They are very personable and their rates are very competitive.
The great thing I found is with your rental they provide straps that you can easily put the paddle boards on your roof of your car! they are foam cushioned and I was able to put 2 paddle boards on my Acura within minutes and it's very easy. They'll show you how and assist. That really helped as not everyone has SUV's or Vans.
Please know this, as I found out the hard way and I guess they thought I knew but you need to purchase a pass for Saguaro Lake to have access. ****You can't buy the pass there at the lake!!!**** There are various locations and I think the nearest one is the CVS literally across parking lot from the store. We found out hard way and had to drive 9 miles to a gas station after getting to the park. That's ridiculous they don't sell passes there! Alas, this was no fault of NoSnow SUP, I just wasn't aware.
To my knowledge this is the only other paddle board rental place around so give them a shot!