I've lived in the Village for a year and a half, and I love going to the Church Street Diner. I've taken my parents there, my friends there, and I rave about it to anyone looking for a reasonably priced breakfast.
I have never tried their lunch menu, but my parents did and said it was excellent.
Their eggs benedict is delicious and the eggs have always been pouched perfectly for me. Their homefries are good and they give you a good portion size. It's something you can finish off without feeling like you won't be able to move for the rest of day, but they definitely never leave you hungry.
Their baked eggs are also really nice and flavourful.
Their staff has always been really friendly and attentive and even though the diner only seats a handful of people at any time, I've never had to wait terribly long to get a seat.
I don't know how this place was before it closed and reopened, but I've never had a bad experience here, so the rest of the reviews boggle me.