This place gives me such conflicted feelings. If I were rating it on the food alone, it would have been a 5 star place for sure. Even the bread with butter.. the butter is whipped with honey and it pairs well with the warm bread. I would buy it by the gallon if I could. We ordered the cheddar pierogies as an appetizer. They had a nice peppery kick and were perfectly cooked, served with a side of herbed sour cream. Our appetizers, the meatloaf and the crab cakes, were delicious.
I took away two stars due to the ambience. This place doesn't know whether it wants to be fancy or your neighborhood bar. The beautiful chandelier when you walk in is a nice touch alongside the more rustic elements... but I could have done without the jukebox blaring Creed and Ke$ha for the entirety of our meal.
Other notes: decent beer selection, servers were really nice but the kitchen was slow.