First time experiencing Peppi's and it did not disappoint. I love the whole feel and set up of this place. After ordering our sandwiches at the counter, we took a seat in the dining room and I immediately became caught up with looking at all of the people photos lining the walls and with reading some of the various business cards patrons have placed under the wooden strips along an area inside the dining area. Perhaps I will decide to give Good Fellas Remodeling a call...or maybe not! The Phantom Steak hoagie was very enjoyable and filling. I am looking forward to another go at Peppi's!