5 stars for ambiance, 3 stars for food.
It's hard to know what to expect when you walk into the Italian Society of Madison (this is so not what it's actually called but bear with me). The foyer looks like a foyer for a local society, not for a restaurant. But that's what makes Greenbush Bar so special - you walk down the side steps and are transported to another world! The ceilings are low and there are colorful Christmas lights hanging. It's dim and cozy with a big bar lining one of the sides. I would call it supper club meets speakeasy? The type of speakeasy that the 99% enjoyed during prohibition.
After the excitement from the aesthetics of the joint, we were a little disappointed with the food. Our pizza was fine but all pizza tastes good (check out that Billy Crystal quote - even when it's bad, it's good). It wasn't up there with Grampa's or Pizza Brutta. The crust was thin and too flaky and overcooked. The meat antipasti platter was okay, but not the highest quality. Parts of it seemed like they put Oscar Meyer cold cuts on a dish.
That said, it wasn't a BAD meal. I'll definitely be back to try different menu items and enjoy the special atmosphere!