It's not fancy, but solid, basic Italian food at good prices and the servers were very nice. The meatballs that people rave about were just "ok" to us. If not for the BYOB policy on wine, I would've give it a 3 star rating, but we took a really good Pinot that would've cost a ton at restaurant prices.
Get there early or be ready to wait on a weekend. Also bring cash - no credit cards!