I went to Nicantoni's because I wanted to try some local flavor... we did a *ahem* Citysearch for pizza and came across Nicantoni's. Let me tell you... from first bite... I realized what a real pizza is supposed to be! I have not gone back to the Domino's, Pizza Hut, Papa Johns way of life.
Not sure if it's changed, but the one drawback was being closed on Sunday. Yeah, I realize all those workers need a day off... but man, there are some Sundays I sit at home and WISH I had a Nic pizza.
Our order is always a large pepperoni, small cheese, and two cannoli.
Excellent service, super friendly, HIGHLY recommended!!