I would say this gets 4.75 stars and I round up!
The good: The food is OUT OF SIGHT! At least as good as I have ever had and a few items that are off the CHARTS good! The two items that come to mind is the mac and cheese and the brisket. Both are the best I have ever had. The portions are HUGE!!! I love that as big as I am (6'5, 260) I can easily make two meals out of their 3 meat combo.
The service is great and they really make you feel at home. You feel apart of the family and I love that type of experience!
The bad: There is no indoor seating. The drive is LONG if you live in the south side of town.