I'll just get this part out of the way; they make the best pancakes I have ever had, in my life. Ever.
OK now to the rest. I've eaten here 4 different times now and each time has been quite good. To be fair though, I've eaten breakfast every time I have gone. The service is friendly and quick. The food is terrific and the prices are very reasonable given the quality of the cooking. I would definitely recommend Gus's Diner over any of the other establishments on that side of Verona.