As far as I'm concerned, anyone who wrote a bad review had a bad day and took it out on this place. So just ignore them completely, they clearly don't know what they're talking about.
I've been here a multitude of times and I've always been treated with the utmost courtesy. I come here with the girlfriend occasionally after work because I work in the area. It's a great place to have a drink or two after a long day of work and just unwind. Pete and his wife are just amazing people, and their drink list is superb! (You have to try the Girl Scout, it's amazing. It's literally a thin mint Girl Scout cookie that will get you drunk).
I think the prices are more than fair, considering how creative every drink is and how amazing he service is. This place deserves so much more than five stars.
Personally speaking, I love the atmosphere, it's cozy and welcoming. Everyone here is so nice! You have to check this place out if you're in the area!