I never went into the old Tip Top (because I was far too terrified) but there is no way it held a candle to the current Tip Top.
Basically, the place looks fantastic from ceiling to floor. It now makes sense why the remodel took so long and it was clearly worth the wait. It's exactly what you'd want a neighborhood bar to be. Small but not too small, inviting atmosphere, comfortable lighting, and no over the top decorating.
I had a beer and a very good whisky sour. Looking forward to heading back soon.