I'm caught in the middle....I've been going to the Vintage Vig for a little bit now so when they opened up the Vig Uptown...I'm not gonna lie, it took me a few months before I checked it out......but I'm glad I did.
While I love the "old" Vig for it's awesome patio ( usually...not during the summer, of course) and great service, I love the new Vig for its decor, great drink specials, stellar service....and it's a little more geographically desirable.
The Arizona Room did trip me out at first because I assumed sitting up at the bar that it was a patio but it's actually nice being able to feel like you're SORT of outside without really being outside. The wall to leave your mark on is fun! It's an interesting little addition and it's entertaining to see what some people put up.
The guac and chips are good as are the sliders aka The Trifecta...can't go wrong with the shoe string fries. Once again, I'm going to have to head over there on an empty stomach to really test it out one of these days.
I can agree with most on the valet; the guys are really nice but there's tons of other spots to park at if you aren't super lazy and wanna cross the street (or head next door).
All in all, give the Vig a go.