Secret's out of the bag: Fashionably yours is my go-to consignment spot in Toronto.
The customer service is great; everyone is super friendly and will take their time to show you everything you want to see. The selection varies from time to time and you have to frequent the store on a regular basis, however, I have found some great items and the staff is fair when it comes to price adjustments. It is true that some items are over-priced but some are a steal. The shoe selection is quite high-end. If you decide to consign, the split is 50/50; however, if something of yours sells this month, you don't get your money until the 15th of the next month which in my opinion, is the only downside to this establishment. They do have a consignor log-in on their website which allows you to see if your items sold or not.