Decor was severely dated, and would've preferred a different selection of background music for my meal (maybe some Dean Martin, not Lady Gaga at an Italian restaurant). Despite the awful impression upon arrival, the food was above average in both taste and portion size. Service wasn't the greatest, but was at least polite.
Wife and I agreed that, when we want a short-distance Italian meal, this now trumps the local Olive Garden because of value. Not a place to take anyone you're looking to impress, though.