I went here with high expectations because of BlogTO's recommendation, but I didn't quite like their fish-- too greasy on the underside and all mushy inside. I noticed they have small portions too. Would rather go to John's Fish and Chips in the west end which has bigger servings for less. I liked Penrose's chips though because they're not soggy and the place is quite charming, like a diner-type resto. Then again I'd probably come back to try their lemon meringue pie, and perhaps another go at their fish-- might have just caught them on a bad day.