I have to completely disagree with the original poster about DiVito's. Yes, the shop is tiny and the restaurant is old fashioned, but they make up for it with a killer pie. Maybe it is a little bit of childhood nostalgia as this was our pizza shop of choice growing up, but I love this pizza. The pie is large, and all of the ingredients are quality. I have been eating a half sausage mushroom, half Canadian bacon and pineapple. The crust is more of a traditional new york style, but the pizza is not super thin with a big crust either. It's a great pie and worth every dollar.
I have had other meals from DiVito's and while they are good, I still wouldn't order anything other than the pizza. The stuffed shells and manacotti are very good.