I've come here once and grabbed a couple pies to go and 4 frozen pies for later. My verdict? If you can go to Kanga Pies (downtown Toronto) instead, go! It's so much better and tastier.
My issue with Pie Guyz was their crust was super soggy at the bottom vs. crunchy. It fell apart when you turned it over. Baking their frozen pies was even more soggy! Kanga's are always crispy and come out perfect from the oven.
I've had a couple flavours from here - the butter chicken, chicken pot pie, steak, and lamb so far. The lamb was the only one that's been flavourful.
Again, if you're craving savoury pies and can't go too far, this isn't bad. But if you can avoid this place and try some of its more superior competitors in pies (Kanga and The Pie Commission), definitely do so instead.
On the plus side, the owner is very friendly!