I have to agree with a lot of what reviewer Catherine M said.
I had a hankering for some fish & chips and had been eyeing this menu. I ordered the Halibut combo which consisted of two pieces of fish and a portion of fries. Drinks and sauces were to be purchased separately, including the tartar sauce which other places include at no additional price. With a small tip included I paid $11.
After ringing the old school bell on the counter, service was prompt. I can't say I've ever encountered a bell on a counter anywhere else and I thoroughly enjoyed dinging it. I was greeted by a "hipster" who was indeed playing interesting music (today's selection was underground hip hop). He quickly became distracted by what seemed like a personal call and I started missing the nice Asian duo that normally looked back at me from behind the counter at my regular joint. My food was quick to be done and was packed up in a fun take-away box.
I have to agree with other reviewers who were a bit put off by the batter. While I didn't think it was way too much, it was a tad on the thick side and a smidge on the squishy side. The fish itself was incredibly delicious and kept me wondering if I was eating chicken or fish, it was so thick and flavourful. It also makes me wonder if it was what I ordered since I though Halibut was one of the darker fish, hence it's lower price.
The fries here are more crispy than at Harbord but you get twice as many at Harbord as you do here. Also, these ones come pre-salted whereas at Harbord you add what you want.
Overall, I though this place was "Meh, I've experienced better" ...at Harbord Fish & Chips. Please no one tell Harbord that I sampled another joint's goods. I was tempted once but I will be unfaithful no more.