Prices very reasonable, baristas and fellow coffee/tea drinkers generally friendly. Very laid-back atmosphere; it doesn't get loud and I never feel guilty for lingering with my laptop. I don't find the coffee to be the best in town, and at times it can be p slow (only ever one barista)... but although they're equidistant from my house, I'll keep picking EVP over the Johnson Public House, which makes me feel uncool and broke.
Nitpicks: some chairs more sittable than others, appear to have gotten rid of salads so that there are no fruit/vegetable options (much less anything with protein-- this is not a place to attempt to have lunch)
Perks (lol): soup of the day is often excellent, you can put your own doodles under the glass tabletops, hot cider is like $1.50 and comes with a whole cinnamon stick in it that can be used as a delicious straw, good chance of meeting friendly dogs.