I honestly can't believe I haven't written a review for Mitchell's yet. I've lived in Cleveland for about three years, and my favorite place by FAR is Mitchell's. I have already started stockpiling it for my upcoming move out of the area. The ice cream is so creamy and so full of flavor. I haven't had a flavor that I didn't like yet, but some of my faves include Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup, Campfire Smores, and Pumpkin Spice. The sundaes are HUGE and amazing. Their homemade whipped cream and Bordeaux soaked cherries really makes the experience different from your run of the mill ice cream places. You MUST TRY the hot fudge. It's amazing. I am sure there is a better adjective, but you gotta try it out. I think I'm drooling now thinking about it. I've recently tried out their milkshakes, and they are definitely worth every.single.calorie.
The stores are always super clean in front and have that amazing waffle cone smell that lets your belly know what treats you have in store for it. The workers are always delightful and act like my obsession with Mitchell's is completely normal