3.5 stars (I wish Yelp would give us half-stars already). Citizen Pie is a fine pizza place. They use a wood fired oven to prepare your "personal" pizza (although I would say two could share one pie) with fresh ingredients.
As a general rule when trying a new pizza place on my own I try to stick with just cheese, and MAYBE pepperoni, because I want to understand the base pizza they're starting from. In this case I ordered both; one cheese and one pepperoni (shared with a friend with the same view as my own). The crust was chewy and flavorful; my personal favorite part of the experience. Lacking for me was the sauce and the cheese. Nothing terrible, just sorta there. Service and cleanliness receive high marks, and the price was reasonable.
I will definitely return to Citizen Pie in the near future, and venture further into their various pizza offerings. But on a baseline level, I would say that their pizza is just above average. Not the best I've ever had, but clearly not the worst either.