Blows the Old Fashioned out of the water.
My office is less than a block away, and I have gained probably 5 pounds from the beer-battered fries alone. Not to mention the PBR-battered fish tacos, the satisfying and well-crafted Tipsy Burger, or any other sumptuous morsel off their menu. Hell-o, weekly specials.
The place is cozy, the bartenders are friendly, and the place is always bustling. It does get very busy very suddenly and wait times tend to be long, what with the no reservation policy. But hey, you've got some nice Wisconsin beers to sip while you wait for the servers to finish hyperventilating in the back.