One word...Ribs! They fall off the bone and are so tasty! One of the more expensive items on the menu at $22, but well worth it. If I'm in a sandwich mood, which I am frequently, then I go with the roast beef, which comes with a nice side of au jus and horseradish sauce. Service is great and we normally just grab a seat at the huge bar and start with the double dip appetizer (half guac/half cold cheese dip w/chips).
Only 2 TV's so not the best place to catch the game, but the outdoor patio and fire pit make for a nice glass of wine on a cool night. And as other people have mentioned, the banana cream pie is one of the best desserts in town!