I moved away from Madison about three years ago, and I was just chatting with an old friend about Flat Top and how much I miss it! There are a few similar places in and around the twin cities, and I've tried almost all of them, but none of them compare!
I LOVE how Flat Top has the meat fresh and in a separate bowl than your veggies/carbs. They have a great selection of sauces and veggies to add. I also really like how they give you a stick with your name on it so you don't lose track of your bowl. Another positive is the free extras you can add to your bowl. Eggs, flat bread, and tofu! (At least this was the case the last time I ate there). You can also add a shrimp skewer for an added price.
The service was always great there even when it was really busy. They also have flavored lemonades with free refills which were great! I think i've tried all the flavors.
Yum, I can't wait to go back when I'm visiting Madison!