I probably would have given this restaurant 2 1/2 stars if I could have, but didn't think it deserved a 3 star rating. The term "meh" definitely applies here - nothing exciting with the food, drinks, service or atmosphere. The homemade chips, guac and salsa were all bland and the portion size was very small. My sandwich and my dining companions' burgers were very bland. Oh, and don't order the sweet potato fries.
If you're looking for a burger/sandwich/fry place you can find much better in Madison, or even Middleton!