After my 3rd visit here, I have decided that I am a fan. I think they've improved on their cookie recipe to make them soft and delectable. I remember the first time I ate here, 2 years ago, their cookies were so hard, I could barely bite through them after they hardened with the ice cream. They have definitely improved on their recipe and I urge people to re-try it if the cookies were what turned them off. The best combination ever: chocolate malt crunch with one tuxedo cookie (milk & white chocolate) and one white chocolate macadamia nut. The sandwiches are very large, so I think splitting one for kids is the appropriate amount or else it would be too large of a sugar bomb.
We had a coupon from valpak or something for b1g1 free, but it seems like there are MANY ways to walk out of there with a discount, that they've displayed all through the store (FB check ins, 4square check ins, Yelp). Overall, we got 2 sandwiches for $3.70 something which is a crazy deal! My kids loved creating their own flavors (with a little parental assistance because chocolate chip cotton candy doesn't sound very appealing) so we will be back.