I'm usually not a big fan of build-your-own pizza restaurants due to lack of actual pizza taste (excluding toppings), but this place is legit. I purposely ordered Cheese Pizza so I could taste the pizza. I guess you could call it Naked Pizza.
Anyway, it was pretty darn good! It was by far the best build-your-own pizza I have ever eaten. After finishing my first personal pie, I wanted to order another one, but I restrained myself. The gelato is good, but I wasn't as impressed by it as I was the pizza. If you want incredible gelato, go to Alino in Mooresville.
Two other big pluses for Your Pie:
1. The owner is super friendly and professional. You can tell he really cares about high quality and taking care of his customers.
2. There is a mini-bar with beers on tap. Pretty cool for a build-your-own pizza joint.
Definitely recommended.