The adorable space (cozy, warm and inviting) bumps this place up to 3 stars. I've been here twice now and neither visit has been overly impressive. First visit I had tried one of their tea lattes and it arrived lukewarm. My second visit I tried a light roast and a pb chocolate cookie bar - coffee was very acidic and the bar was obviously tasty. Their drink prices seem a touch high to me and while all the treats in their bakery case look tasty, there are no descriptions or prices listed, so you either have to ask or just guess. And I agree with a previous review on the speed of the service - slooww! Their 'baristas' are pretty young and maybe a bit inexperienced. Both of my visits were during the day, so I'm not sure how speedy they are during the morning rush, but they also don't open until 7am on weekdays. This area of Madison needs some more coffee house options, so they've got that going for them.