I feel like The Tipsy Cow is the forgotten family member to The Old Fashioned.
They have phenomenal food- the cheese curds and fried pickles are a must every time I go. The beer selection isn't as lengthy as you'd expect, but the options are nothing short of delectable. The Tipsy Cow is a pretty representation of a Wisconsin bar scene.
I've ordered a hamburger from here and was surprised it didn't come with fries (that's where the curds and pickles come into play). Prices are a bit higher than you'd expect, but the quality outdoes itself. Being a New Yorker, I'd say overall fair.
They don't have many specials from what I've seen, but they do have a happy hour.