Was staying one night in Middleton and needed a great spot for Sunday night dinner and located this gem here. Housed in a historic building in old town Middleton, they serve a great selection of pub food -sandwiches, burgers and wraps along with a variety of local brews and cocktails.
It was a mild night so we sat on the secluded outdoor patio starting with barrel-aged Old Fashioned cocktails (among the best I've ever tasted) and some cheese curds (arrived super fast, even beat the drinks to the table!), very fresh and hot.
For dinner I chose the roasted turkey sandwich with cheese and bacon while others in the group had the walleye po'boy (a bit spicy) and the pulled pork sandwich (tangy and sweet). All the food was top notch and arrived very quickly (they weren't super busy).
Service was good and I'd definitely go back there again.