Antney's is definitely a local favorite and I feel slightly guilty for not giving it 5 stars considering the consensus believes this place is phenomenal. Please hear me out as to why it's not my favorite ice cream spot in town.
My one and only complaint: the ice cream here is just a bit too salty for my taste. I am totally all for a pinch of salt in desserts to bring out the flavors, but I've been to Antney's a few times now and each flavor I've sampled or ordered has always been too strong on the salt for me, personally. I feel that their ice cream is always leaving me thirsty for a drink.
Otherwise, this place is a hit. The ice cream flavors are so unique and I like that they rotate them so there's always something new to try. The service has also always been friendly and quick. The lines look long, but they move fast so don't make that stop you from giving it a try.