I can really only rate Tommy's based on milkshakes and milkshake service...
Which were both good. Young kids making milkshakes with very little enthusiasm or knowledge on why anyone would want to try their milkshakes. For a place staking claims on being the "best milkshake" this side of the mississippi you'd think the people making em could have a favorite or at least know what to recommend.
Alas, they don't. You pick from their list of ice creams, they blend it up with a smile and hand it over with a boba sized straw - perfect for the thick ice cream shake.
I had three shakes during my two week stay in Cleveland. I love milkshakes. Here they aren't creative or made with homemade ice cream - a la Crown Candy - but the ice cream they use is tasty and you can mix em up however you want.
- magical milkshake: chocolate, peanut butter (this they make in house), and toffee crunch (special flavor - not sure they carry regularly)
- solidly good: black cherry chip and toffee crunch
- yummy but sweet: black raspberry chip